Land and Housing | Policy Research & Advocacy Series
Vision of Universal Affordable Housing in Hong Kong
Our Hong Kong Foundation (OHKF) has just released our new housing policy initiative, namely “Vision of Universal Affordable Housing in Hong Kong”. Through our research, we found that property prices have increased by more than five times over the past 15 years, while median household income has just increased by a meagre 80% over the same period. This reflects the growing gap between those with properties and those without. In view of this, we hope our new initiative could provide the government and the community with a comprehensive housing policy blueprint that could narrow the wealth gap between the “haves” and the “have-nots”.
We have made reference to the Singaporean housing model to outline a viable path based on the circumstances in Hong Kong. We believe the only way to tackle the current housing crisis is to understand the problems faced by different sectors of the society.
Through a set of ten policy recommendations, such as the refined Tenants Purchase Scheme (TPS 2.0), a Buy-or-Rent Option for new public housing, rent subsidies, fixed premium, and interest-free loans to first-time buyers, etc., the initiative aims at providing assistance for the achievement of homeownership for all sectors of the society: existing Public Rental Housing (PRH) tenants, households on the PRH waiting list or currently living in sub-divided units, owners of Subsidised Sale Flats (SSFs) with premium unpaid, White Form households, and young first-time homebuyers. The ultimate goal is to enable 70% to 80% of Hong Kong citizens to eventually become owners of permanent properties and be able to share the fruits of economic prosperity.
Land and Housing Policy Advocacy Series 4: Hanging on the Housing Supply Cliff - Are There More Bandages Around?
Our Hong Kong Foundation (OHKF) has launched the fourth report of its "Land and Housing Policy Advocacy” series, “Hanging on the Housing Supply Cliff: Are There More Bandages Around?”. We address the housing crisis faced by the city, towards which public attention has waned in recent months despite its persistent severity. Unfortunately, OHKF’s updated forecasts show that the worst is yet to come.
A continual depletion of the city's land bank means that sharp drops will be seen in both private and public housing supply in a few years' time. Our average annual private housing supply forecast for 2019-2023 has been adjusted downwards by 11% compared to our previous rolling five-year forecast for 2018-2022. In particular, completions in 2023 is forecast to drop to only 13,300 units, nearly 40% lower than the corresponding figure in 2018.
For the next four years, public housing supply is forecast to be 10% lower compared to the previous rolling four years. We expect the Government’s target of 31,500 units per year to be missed by a large shortfall of 42%. Over a 10-year horizon, we expect a cumulative shortfall of 85,000 units. We also expect the general applicants’ average waiting time for public rental housing to exceed 6 years in three years’ time.
In view of the significant shortfalls in public housing in the next 10 years, we urge the Government and society-at-large to speed up all land rezoning efforts, which is the main source of land supply in the short-to-medium term. We examined the potential rezoning sites demarcated by the Government in detail and prioritised different sites based on their difficulty-levels regarding the rezoning process.
OHKF also covers the issue of "brownfield" sites as important economic ancillary land to Hong Kong, and call for a comprehensive review by the Government for the current and future demand of land to facilitate the trading and logistics industry.
Land and Housing Advocacy Study: Downward Spiral of Housing Demand Estimation
Our Hong Kong Foundation (OHKF) released its Land & Housing Advocacy Study ”Downward Spiral of Housing Demand Estimation" in response to the Government's updated Long Term Housing Strategy (LTHS). We observe that the demand for housing in the LTHS has continually been underestimated, failing to take into account the pent-up demand accumulated over the past decade. The adjustment of the housing supply target's public-private ratio from 60:40 to 70:30 fails to increase the overall target, and merely "robs one's belly to cover one's back".
Regarding private housing, there is now a lower annual average supply target. We also find that the availability of spade ready land for private housing development has fallen behind for the first time in four years, meaning that future completions will see a sharp downturn.
Taking into account the completion forecasts for the next four years, the Government will fail to meet its first 10-year public housing supply target announced four years ago. Also, in the past year, the Government has only been able to source land for public housing by reallocating land from private housing. Complications with rezoning, increased plot ratios and more have contributed to more delays in the delivery of public housing.
Re-imagining Hong Kong with a Game-Changer: Enhanced East Lantau Metropolis
Our Hong Kong Foundation (OHKF) has released their most significant research report since their inception three and a half years ago. They propose to construct an island in the waters between Hong Kong Island and Lantau that will become the base of a smart and liveable metropolis that can accommodate up to about a million people. The proposed island will have a land area of 2,200 hectares, equivalent to half the size of Kowloon. In order to strike a balance between environmental protection / ecological conservation and economic development, OHKF partnered with internationally-renowned management consultant, McKinsey & Company; engineering consultant, Arup; environmental consultant, Environmental Resources Management (ERM); and traffic management consultant, OZZO Technology (HK) Ltd, to jointly conduct preliminary studies on multiple aspects including water depth, hydrodynamics, marine traffic and operations, engineering work, costs, various land restrictions, and submarine utilities.
As seen in the past experiences of developing the new towns of Sha Tin, Tuen Mun, Tseung Kwan O and Tung Chung, Hong Kong with its natural hilly terrain has tackled the shortage of land through reclamation. However, Hong Kong has lagged behind Singapore, Macau, Shenzhen and Saemangeum in South Korea in terms of large-scale reclamation in the past decade - a period when Hong Kong simply halted land creation despite growing social and economic needs. OHKF’s proposal builds on the Government’s strategic plan of the East Lantau Metropolis mentioned in “Hong Kong 2030+”, and suggests an even bolder, more forward-looking and imaginative, and considerably bigger undertaking of reclamation to create an "Enhanced East Lantau Metropolis”.
Land and Housing Policy Advocacy Series 3: Lacunae in Land Planning: Undersized, Undersupplied and Underestimated
Our Hong Kong Foundation (OHKF) launched the third report of its "Land and Housing Policy Advocacy” series,“Lacunae in Land Planning: Undersized, Undersupplied and Underestimated”today. The shortage of land supply continues to put Hong Kong in a dire situation where housing – a priority concerning the public with significant implications – is regressively undersized, undersupplied and underestimated. It has caused local property prices to skyrocket beyond the norm of inflation, depressed the quality of life below historical trends, and hurt the city’s long-term competitiveness as a centre of international business. As such, Our Hong Kong Foundation (OHKF) believes that land and housing is currently one of Hong Kong’s greatest challenges.
We have noted the average size of newly constructed residential units in recent years to be substantially smaller compared to the previous norm. Also, we have found that rezoning has become the primary means of land supply, which is highly uncertain and ineffective. More importantly, we have found the actual demand for land and housing to be far greater than that anticipated in the government consultation, “Hong Kong 2030+: Towards a Planning Vision and Strategy Transcending 2030. We believe Hong Kong will need more than 9,000 hectares of new land (roughly three times the size of Sha Tin) over the next three decades, instead of 4,800 hectares as estimated by the government. Compared to other avenues of land supply, OHKF believes that reclamation is the only way of providing Hong Kong with high-quality land as a long-term solution. Hence, OHKF reiterates its suggestion to the government to consider it as a viable option to tackle the mounting challenge of land and housing shortage.
Land and Housing Policy Research Series 3: Housing Policy Reform to Narrow Wealth Gap Urgent Formation of Land to Improve People’s Livelihood
Our Hong Kong Foundation (“OHKF”) has launched the third report of its Land and Housing Research Series today. The report intricately analyses defects in the design of the existing public housing mechanism and its associated inefficiencies. These include a severe lack of opportunity for PRH tenants to move between units, unsustainable burden on public finance, etc. In response, OHKF believes that housing policy must be transformed to become homeownership-oriented. This can ameliorate issues derived from income disparity and intergenerational poverty. To share wealth with the people, the report recommends that the government implement the “Subsidised Homeownership Scheme”, with prices of public housing units linked to the development costs and the unpaid premium capped at the date of occupation and thus delinked with the fluctuating market value.
As a continuation of OHKF’s advocacy report “From Large-Scale Reclamation to an Ideal Home” published in April this year, the second part of this report continues to explore issues relating to land supply. It proposes short, medium and long-term solutions to the severe land shortages faced by the city. In the short to medium-term, OHKF recommends implementing a Public-Private Partnership (PPP) scheme to release the development potentials of privately-owned land and increase the supply of housing. In the long-term, the report stresses again that the ideal solution is large-scale reclamation outside Victoria Harbour to create large, flat and high-quality developable land and build a significant land reserve.
Land and Housing Policy Advocacy Series 2: From Large Scale Reclamation to an Ideal Home
Our Hong Kong Foundation (OHKF) launched the second report of its "Land and Housing Policy Advocacy” series, “From Large-Scale Reclamation to an Ideal Home”, in response to the government’s “Hong Kong 2030+: Towards a Planning Vision and Strategy Transcending 2030” consultation. OHKF forecasts that the average completion of private residential units to be 20,200 in 2017 to 2020, which meets the target set by the LTHS and is 85% higher than that of the preceding decade. However, public housing is still chronically undersupplied, and the average waiting time of public rental housing has increased rapidly. In the long term, OHKF estimates that Hong Kong will require more than 1.26 million units of housing over the next 30 years, translating into more than 9,000 hectares of land. Yet, the government’s existing land development plans can only provide 5,300 hectares of land.
Hong Kong’s development is a story of reclamation. It is not only the cornerstone of the development of new towns, but also an important source of land for public and private housing. But in recent years, reclamation have halted, and Hong Kong is seriously falling behind its neighbours. As a result, the residential land available for reclamation from the past will soon be depleted. To ensure the continued and stable supply of land and establish a land reserve in the long-term, OHKF suggests that the Government should restart large-scale reclamation and proposes a number of reclamation sites. Together, we can build our “New Rose Garden”. In the short and medium term, OHKF recommends the government to consider ways of releasing private land bank to increase housing supply through public-private partnerships.
Land and Housing Policy Research Series 2: Rethinking Public Housing Policy Building Sustainable Land Reserve
[Download Full Report]
[Download Part One Executive Summary - The Price of Our Public Housing Programme]
[Download Part Two Executive Summary - Macro Considerations Surrounding Land Supply]
[Download Part One - The Price of Our Public Housing Programme]
[Download Part Two - Macro Considerations Surrounding Land Supply]
Our Hong Kong Foundation (OHKF) releases its second public policy research report in the area of land and housing. The report recommends that the Government implement the “Subsidised Homeownership Scheme” (SHS) and change the existing mechanism determining the unpaid premium by fixing the amount at the time of purchase, so that households will no longer have to catch up with ever-increasing property prices. The report also examines the malign issues arising from the current public housing policy alongside the urgency and necessity of implementing the SHS. OHKF believes that the proposed Scheme will help grass-roots families purchase their own homes and in the long-term, improve social mobility, alleviate income inequality and inter-generational poverty.
Moreover, the report extends the findings of OHKF’s previous research entitled "From Housing Market Outlook to Land Supply Strategy" published in July. It is proposed that Government should strive to establish a land reserve and to implement the Lantau Development as soon as possible, and calls for greater societal cohesion and consensus to support land development. Land supply involves the interests of the community as a whole. OHKF believes that mere debates and arguments will not help improve the situation. Only by recognising the severity and urgency of the problem of land and housing shortages, and supporting faster land development, can ensure that Hong Kong enjoys a sustainable future.
Land and Housing Policy Advocacy Series 1: From Housing Market Outlook to Land Supply Strategy
Our Hong Kong Foundation (OHKF) releases its research report “From Housing Market Outlook to Land Supply Strategy” today. OHKF believes that whilst housing supply is expected to increase, demographic structure and other socio-economic indicators suggest that there is still an abundance of genuine end-user demand for housing in Hong Kong, and the medium- to long-term supply situation remains grim. There is no room for the government to slow down in housing and land production. In addition, OHKF opines that given the numerous challenges faced by the development of “brownfield sites”, it is unrealistic for the community to expect it as a prioritised avenue of land supply. Over the longer term, reclamation and developing new towns are still important and the more effective land development options for the city.
Land and Housing Policy Research Series 1: Maximizing Land Use to Boost Development Optimizing Housing Resources to Benefit All
[Download Full Report]
[Download Part One Executive Summary - Subsidized Homeownership Scheme]
[Download Part Two Executive Summary - Increasing Land Supply]
[Download Part One - Subsidized Homeownership Scheme]
[Download Part Two - Increasing Land Supply]
Our Hong Kong Foundation today released our- first research report, with focus on Hong Kong land and housing policies. In housing, we advocate that the Government launch a “Subsidized Homeownership Scheme” to utilize public housing resources more efficiently, to enable the underprivileged to become property owners with policy support, and in the long run to share in the wealth brought by Hong Kong’s economic prosperity.
Housing is inseparable from land supply. In the past decade or so, Hong Kong’s reclamation activities had ground to a halt, and there were very few major land development plans. Our Hong Kong Foundation advocates that the public should look at the macro situation and support a multi-pronged strategy to increase land supply — including reclamation. In the long run, Hong Kong must build its own land reserves to meet various economic, social and livelihood needs.